Speedy BlueThe Diatonic Scale
Imagine you were given a piano with no black keys. You could still produce a familiar do re mi scale and plenty of melodies using the key of C major, as this doesn’t require the sharps or flats of the black keys. Your white keyboard would effectively be a C diatonic keyboard, offering up the notes of the C major scale in each direction from Middle C. The notes of the C major scale are  C   D   E   F   G   A   B and C again. That’s an eight note sequence, or octave. And it’s exactly what’s in our 10 hole diatonic C harp between holes 4 and 7. Try it for yourself  4B    4D    5B    5D    6B    6D    7D   7B. These are our melody, or soloing, notes.

The Chromatic Scale
If we reintroduced the black keys to our piano, it would become a chromatic keyboard, offering us the luxury of ascending and descending in half note steps. If we did so between two C keys an octave apart, the result would be:

Ascending    :  C    C#   D    D#   E    F    F#   G    G#   A    A#   B    C
Descending :  C     B    Bb    A    Ab   G   Gb   F     E     Eb   D    Db  C

CX12 BlackThat’s a thirteen note sequence. And, just in case you’re wondering, yes C# is the same note as Db on a chromatic keyboard. This aspect of musical theory is called enharmonics; two names for the same note. Knowing exactly how, and exactly when to use each, is complicated theory we will save for a rainy day. On diatonic harmonicas, and on a bandstand however, you’ll normally hear the notes of the chromatic scale referred to as follows:

Common use :  C    Db   D    Eb   E    F    F#   G    Ab   A    Bb   B    C

How to crack the modal code
Let’s return to our imaginary diatonic, or white key, piano for a moment. To break the routine of the C major scale outlined above, we could experiment by ascending and descending between other like-notes an octave apart; D to D, or E to E for example. In doing so, we would be entering the magic kingdom of modal scales. Tabbing them for the 10 hole harp in sequence from C, the result is displayed in the chart below left. Take some time now to play each line left to right and right to left (up and down) a few times on your C harp. Listen carefully to the end product in each case and note the different character, or flavour, of each scale. How does each one leave you feeling? Can you find any useful or interesting musical licks? Do any of the scales remind you of tunes you have heard before?

Piano Octave iC     4B   4D   5B   5D   6B   6D   7D   7B
D    4D   5B   5D   6B   6D   7D   7B   8D
E     5B   5D   6B   6D   7D   7B   8D   8B
F     5D   6B   6D   7D   7B   8D   8B   9D
G     6B   6D   7D   7B   8D   8B   9D   9B
A     6D   7D   7B   8D   8B   9D   9B   10D
B     7D   7B   8D   8B   9D   9B   10D  10B

Now let’s analyse what’s actually happening by mapping out the musical steps, or intervals, we’re making in each case. Referring to the chromatic piano keyboard pictured above right will help you visualise what’s happening. We’ll call a whole-tone step T and a half-tone (or semi-tone) step s.

C        T     T     s     T     T     T     s                                 C   D   E   F   G   A   B   C
D        T     s     T     T     T     s     T                                 D   E   F   G   A   B   C   D
E        s     T     T     T     s     T     T                                 E   F   G   A   B   C   D   E
F        T     T     T     s     T     T     s                                 F   G   A   B   C   D   E   F
G        T     T     s     T     T     s     T                                 G   A   B   C   D   E   F   G
A        T     s     T     T     s     T     T                                 A   B   C   D   E   F   G   A
B        s     T     T     s     T      T    T                                 B   C   D   E   F   G   A   B

And this is almost all you need to know – it’s that hard! In the left hand panel above, you can see how the semi-tone steps shift to the left each time we move up a mode. These are the intervals between E and F, and B and C. The right hand panel demonstrates this too. The semitone shifts are what changed the ‘flavour‘ of theChopped garlic i modal scales you played earlier. They move closer to the start note each time you move up; until they eventually become the start note.

Name and shame
I’ve used the term ‘flavour‘ with some forethought. I could have used ‘mood‘ but I don’t want to confuse this with mode, so let’s stick with the cooking metaphor for now. In which case, just as we’ve given each tone a letter of the alphabet, so each of the diatonic recipes above, or modal scales, has a given name (in green):

C        T     T     s     T     T     T     s        Ionian
D        T     s     T     T     T     s     T        Dorian
E        s     T     T     T     s     T     T        Phrygian
F        T     T     T     s     T     T     s        Lydian
G        T     T     s     T     T     s     T       Mixolydian
A        T     s     T     T     s     T     T        Aeolian
B        s     T     T     s     T      T    T        Locrian

Greek HelmetThese are the ancient Greek names attributed to each mode by Pythagoras. Yes the mathematician. You know folks sometimes say music and maths have a lot in common? Well right now you’re at the heart of the matter. The Greeks recognised the science, art and magic of music. Indeed, music was actually part of the ancient Olympic Games.

Pythagoras used musical traditions from remote areas of the known world to describe the character of each mode. The Dorians were one of the four major Greek tribes and came from central Greece – they built temples with plane looking, Doric, capitals to their  columns. Locrians were a minor tribe from north-west mainland Greece. Two of the other major Greek tribes were the Ionians who settled the Ionian seaboard in what is now Turkey, and the Aeolians, originally from Thessaly in mainland Greece. The Phrygian community was from Asia Minor (Turkey), as were the Lydians of Anatolia. Mixolydian means half, or almost, Lydian, and is a technical afterthought rather than an actual Greek tribe of small stature.

Nouvelle cuisine
Relating each of the modal scales to parts of the known world made the ‘flavour‘ of the mode more meaningful to the Greek listener. In the post-modern world we might call Phrygian the Spanish or Moorish mode, Lydian the Scottish mode, Aeolian the Klezmer or Yiddish mode and Dorian the English Folk mode. Meanwhile, philosophers ancient and modern might describe the ‘feeling‘ or ‘mood-changing‘ effect of each mode in the following way:

Ionian             Harmonious or tender
Dorian            Serious or melancholic
Phrygian        Mystic
Lydian             Happy or vibrant
Mixolydian     Angelic or youthful
Replacement Reed SetAeolian           Sad or tearful
Locrian           Wistful or yearning

Getting real with it
Now that the underlying theory is clearer, one glaringly important question arises; what practical use is there for musical modes while playing the diatonic harmonica? The answer in one word is, lots! But first let’s translate everything into harp speak.

To start with, it’s useful to equate each mode name with a standard key name. We’ll then need to agree a useful root note, or start point, for each key; officially called the point of resolution. Finally, it helps to find a memorable tune we can use as an aide memoire to recall each mode in a practical sense. Using a C harmonica, our shortlist might look like this:

Mode                Key                    Root Note(s)         Memorable tune
Ionian              C major              4B, 1B, 7B, 10B     When The Saints Go Marching In
Dorian             D minor             4D, 1D, 8D             Scarborough Fair / Drunken Sailor
E  minor             5B, 2B, 8B              Knights in White Satin / Misirlou
Lydian             F major               5D, 9D, 2D”           Au Claire de la Lune / Price Tag / Simpsons Theme
Mixolydian     G major              2D, 6B, 9B             Norwegian Wood / Clocks (Cold Play)
Aeolian           A minor              6D, 3D”, 10D         When Johnny Comes Marching Home / Losing My Religion
B diminished     3D, 7D                    She’s A Rainbow

Running around in circles
Some of you may be thinking this is all very user-friendly, but you’d really like to get some engine oil under your fingernails. OK, roll your sleeves up, it’s time to haul the whole thing onto the inspection ramp. To truly relate the concept of modes to the 10 hole diatonic harp, we have to embrace a pivotal subject of musical theory. It’s one that can quickly cause harp playing eyes to glaze over; the circle of fifths (or positional playing). Trust me when I say it’s really quite simple. If I can get it, so can you. Let’s gently set the ball rolling using a C harp.

We know we can play any number of straight harp tunes, including When The Saints Go Marching In, from 4B right? We also know this is called 1st Position (Straight Harp). Well, to put it politely, these tunes soon feel pedestrian. We want to rock it up and play like Little Walter. So we find ourselves flipping through pages until we come to Cross Harp, where we adopt 2D as our root and range up and down between it and 6B. We then start to investigate draw bends. Marine Band CrossoverAs we do so, we’re probably aware that we’re playing in G major. We also know this as 2nd Position.

But let’s revisit what just happened for moment. To reach G from C, we’ve ascended 5 degrees, or notes, of the major scale. If we wanted to use posh musical vocabulary, we could call this a diatonic interval of 5. We’ve gone from C, through  D   E   F up to  G in 5 steps. Remember that we include the root note of C as step 1 when we start counting. It’s like the working week from Monday to Friday – five days in all. Hold that thought.

XB-40 Bending Harp

Step back baby, step back
Stepping back into modal terms for a moment (and once again if I can do this, you can too, so stay with it), we’ve moved from Ionian (C) in root note 4B, to Mixolydian (G) in root note 2D. Et voila! It’s that simple. We’ve worked our way from 1st to 2nd position, from 4B to 2D, from Ionian to Mixolydian and it’s all making sense. Ready for the next step?

If we counted up another interval of 5 from G, we’d reach D and that would be Dorian mode. Which is 3rd position from 4D. Hold up the fingers and thumb of either hand and count this out across your digits: G  A  B  C  D. You just used your naturally patented, circle-of fifths, double-checking system. Take it with you wherever you play. By the way, to be absolutely accurate, we actually found D minor. We won’t explain the reason for this right now, as it will interrupt our line of thought. But once you’ve finished this page, had a massage and finished a cold glass of whatever takes your fancy, you can check it all out here.

Back on message. Position-wise, we can keep going round the circle of fifths using our fingers and thumbs until we eventually return to C. In doing so, we will have covered all twelve degrees of the chromatic scale. Or will we? I hear some of you asking ‘how come, when counting round in intervals of 5, it takes us from C to G, G to D, D to A, A to E, E to B, B to F and finally from F to C? That’s only 7 notes on the keyboard, not 12!‘.

Better by half
Harp KeysHere’s the answer. To be empirically accurate, we need to start counting not in diatonic intervals, but in chromatic intervals, or half steps only. This way the chromatic interval between C and G is 8 half-step degrees, instead of five diatonic steps.The keyboard image above will help you visualise this. The chromatic interval from G to D is also 8 half-step degrees. Only now, when we continue counting chromatically, do we actually cover all 12 degrees of the chromatic scale using the white and black keys of our piano keyboard. Let’s check it all out, ascending in 8 half-step intervals from C:

C     G     D     A     E     B     F#    Db    Ab    Eb     Bb   

Bullet mic and score

Well done. Here you have an absolute DNA blueprint for all twelve positions on a C major diatonic harmonica. You can take this same 8 half-step formula, apply it to any key of diatonic harmonica, and work out its integral twelve positional note names.

At the same time, you can confidently accept that you’ll encounter our seven modes as you go (in bold above). The modal positions also happen to be the most practical of the twelve options available to diatonic harp players – 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th and 12th – as the root note is not always hidden in an inconvenient bend. Now, just to round everything off, here are the 7 modes again with their root notes and corresponding position on the harmonica, again using a C major harp.

Mode                Key                    Root Note(s)          Harp Position
Ionian               C major             4B, 1B, 7B, 10B      1st position
Dorian              D minor             4D, 1D, 8D              3rd position
Phrygian          E  minor             5B, 2B, 8B               5th position
Lydian              F major              5D, 9D, 2D”             12th position
Mixolydian      G major             2D, 6B, 9B                2nd position
Aeolian             A minor             6D, 3D”, 10D           4th position
Locrian             B diminished    3D, 7D                      6th position

Welcome to the human race!
If any of this is page unclear, it’s probably because you’re human, or else you’ve been playing your harmonica instinctively. The message is, it’s time to start playing smart as well as hard, so review the information above and add it to your arsenal. We guarantee it will help shape you into a musician.  Very soon you’ll be surprising those who assumed you were just the harp playe’. Now re-read this page until you can comfortably do it all yourself. Then tell all your harp friends where you found the inspiration.

15 thoughts on “Modes

  • April 1, 2016 at 4:46 am

    Your my hero!
    This is, oh so helpful!
    Thank you so much!

  • August 11, 2016 at 6:22 pm

    Well done, as you say, every harmonica player wants to play in a feeling mood instead to learn more of music. Thanks for this.

  • June 16, 2018 at 1:57 pm

    For my limited harp-based musical knowledge, this has been a most enlightening introduction to music theory. I’ve returned to it any number of times over five or so years. Thank you.

  • August 27, 2018 at 7:06 pm

    Yay! Glad it makes sense. That’s very welcome feedback. Tell ALL your friends.

  • November 3, 2018 at 8:47 pm

    Your a great writer, with such ease I actually understood this lesson which I have been trying to find in layman terms for a while now, much appreciated!

  • January 7, 2019 at 8:03 pm

    This was extremely helpful, thank you! Trying to break out of 2nd position. Especially lost when it comes to playing in minor keys. Looks like i need to start practicing new scales. Thanks again!

  • March 18, 2019 at 11:12 am

    Great! Always good to receive your feedback.

  • March 18, 2019 at 11:14 am

    Thank you for your feedback Reith. I’m glad it helped!

  • October 15, 2019 at 2:46 pm

    Good article. Very useful and educational. Congratulations.

  • February 20, 2020 at 2:46 pm

    Thanks Albert. It’s actually a really simple concept. It tends to scare newcomers, when there’s nothing to be afraid of. Glad you found it accessible. Doc

  • April 16, 2020 at 4:08 am

    Wow! Thank you for explaining it so simple and eloquently in layman’s terms. Trying to understanding these musical concepts has been haunting me for a while. I struggled to bend notes (even with face to face instruction) for 6 months, until I stumbled onto Christelle’s page. Her storytelling was my lightbulb moment for bending. And tonight the harp theory lightbulb came on!!

  • April 20, 2020 at 9:40 am

    Hi Joe – thanks for your feedback. Please tell all your harmonica friends you found it here!

  • February 22, 2021 at 3:45 pm

    This is the best information I’ve found on Harmonica, Positions/Modes and how they relate to the Diatonic Harp! Well done my friend. The locks you’ve provided the keys for with this single page, will forever expand my musical comprehension! For the Harp as well as all other instruments!
    Thank You!

  • February 26, 2021 at 6:41 pm

    Cheers Stephen, that’s great feedback. I’m really thrilled it worked so well for you. Please tell all your harp friends about the Harp Surgery. Come say hello at one of our weekly workshops too!

  • April 4, 2021 at 11:45 pm

    Great rundown on technical information for any aspiring harp player. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.